According to Gallup, approval of the USA’s leadership is at the lowest point ever in many, many countries, and to make things worse (1) that includes our most trusted allies and (2) those net approval ratings are so low that it may take years or even decades to turn them around, if they can be turned at all.
Germany: minus 83% (6% approve, 89% disapprove)
The UK: minus 60
Canada: minus 65
The Nordic countries: all minus 60 or worse
Other major European powers: between minus 55 and minus 65
Australia and New Zealand: in the high minus 30s.
Among all the free world powers, only Japan continues to hold a slightly positive view of the USA (39% approve, 38% disapprove).
I guess Americans can take some consolation in the fact that our most powerful geopolitical rivals are just as unpopular. The median positive approval for the USA stands at 18%. Russia and China are almost identical at 19% and 17% respectively.
The world now looks to Germany for leadership. (There’s one of the more frightening sentences written in the past two centuries.)
62% of the people of other countries approve of Germany’s leadership. In fact, even Americans have a higher approval of Germany’s leadership than their own! (Germany’s leadership +29, Trump -12, Congress -50.)
—-
—-
—-
It will not be a simple matter for a post-Trump America to regain its status because Trump set America on a path of disengagement from the world that was often sound even when his rhetoric was undiplomatic, even incendiary. He may have bungled WHO or the climate accords in a fit of pique, but some of his goals were sound: he advocated better control of the borders, an end to military interventionism, greater assumption of financial responsibility from our allies, and greater reciprocity in international agreements.
Biden can mend some of the problems with WHO and the climate accords, but there are things he can’t and shouldn’t change, and those things are important contributors to America’s low leadership ratings. Trump asked the NATO countries to start paying a fair share for their own defense. When they said they were making good progress toward their goals, he first ridiculed their goals, and then pointed out that many countries weren’t even reaching those softball targets. And so they hate him because he is telling them to open their wallets. The problem there is that he was completely correct, and there’s not much Biden can do except to soften the rhetoric.
Similarly, I don’t think that the American public will accept a return to American interventionism except in a unified and global effort that is undeniably in America’s self-interest. And it may have to be in America’s immediate interest rather than as part of a larger, long-term strategy. “Team America: World Police” is likely to become just the name of a film rather than a global reality.
JFK once said, “Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe to assure the survival and the success of liberty.”
That time is gone.
