The office of the White House counsel sent a long letter to Congress saying it would actively resist the impeachment inquiry.
It appears not to have been written by lawyers at all.
————-
=============
Curiously, although the letter is supposed to be from lawyers, it is not a legal argument, but a purely political propaganda statement, the usual “you’re trying to overturn the election” argument. I would be surprised if lawyers wrote this. My guess is that Trump dictated it, one member of the staff cleaned up his grammar, and then a lawyer simply removed anything overtly criminal and added a signature. It sounds exactly like one of Trump’s rally performances, except that it is at least semi-literate.
The lawyers who allegedly compose it don’t seem to know the difference between an impeachment investigation and the subsequent Senate trial, where the President can call any witnesses he cares to, may testify for himself, may review all evidence, and may cross-examine any witnesses. Obviously, lawyers really do know the difference, so we can conclude that the document was not written to be evaluated by jurists, but rather to be read aloud on the Fox News opinion shows, and that the White House Counsel just wrote what Trump told him to write.
It would be a matter for the Senate to decide, but it is likely that refusal to co-operate with a constitutional impeachment process would, in itself, be legitimate grounds for impeachment, just as a murderer could be separately indicted for obstruction of justice for impeding the murder investigation.
But …
It is important to understand that this is a matter of politics, not law. Various sources have estimated that the Senate would produce as many as 30 Republican votes for conviction on the facts of the case if they held a secret ballot, but that only a small number of Republican senators would be willing to risk a public vote for conviction, which is what they would actually have to do. This is a case where the facts are irrelevant because a public vote to convict Trump is highly likely to result in a loss in the next Republican primary. While a plurality of the American public now support Trump’s constitutional removal from office, some 76% of Republicans oppose it.
Speaking frankly, not many American politicians are willing to sacrifice their careers on the altar of truth and justice. Such an offering would require a person to genuinely believe that the fate of the country is more important than his/her individual fate, and I don’t have enough faith in my fellow man to believe there are many politicians with that much integrity. Let’s face it, from the day an American politician takes office, his or her real job is not to serve the country, or even to serve his or her constituents, but rather to be re-elected. And that’s not something for liberals to be smug about because pandering to the base is something done by both parties in approximately equal measure.
