The root of North American comedy.

There is a documentary film called You Had to Be There that is dedicated solely to that 1972 production.

Originally planned for a six-week run at the Royal Alexandra Theatre, the show was so popular that it moved to the Bayview Playhouse and ran for 15 months, but the fact that it was a Toronto phenomenon is not what makes it worthy of a documentary. This show produced a ripple through North American comedy for the next few decades.
* Gilda Radner was in the original cast, and she went on to star as one of the original Not Ready For Prime Time Players on SNL.
* Eugene Levy, Martin Short and Andrea Martin were also in the original cast, and Dave Thomas joined the cast when some of the originals left. Three of them became anchors of the original cast of SCTV, and Short joined the SCTV cast later.
* Paul Shaffer was the musical director. I suppose you know he went on to long stints as the musical director for SNL and David Letterman.
In addition to interviews with the cast members, the film includes actual rehearsal footage, rare stories about how the cast came together, cast bios, and excerpts from Martin Short’s secret bootleg recording of an actual performance. As a finale, the filmmaker also recorded a recent and highly emotional cast reunion.
Here is the actual dress rehearsal footage.
Here is the trailer:
I know that many of you are SCTV superfans, as I am. If you are, this documentary contains 100 minutes of smiles, warm memories, and maybe a tear or two in the final minutes. I watched it twice. Here is the documentary’s home page, with info on how to watch it. Do yourself a favor and do so.
===============
On a personal note …
I spent a lot of time in Toronto during the run of this play, and I was a theater geek myself, doing summer stock just 90 miles away, so you’d think that this production would have been on my radar. It was not. I was completely unaware of the show. This is another demonstration of my general failure to participate in any important event of my generation.
In addition to this, there was Woodstock. I think those millions who claim to have gone to Woodstock don’t have any idea how unlikely their story is. I can speak to that because I actually tried to go to and failed! I was driving down with my friend, and the NY Thruway was jammed, bumper to bumper from the time we got on in Victor, 300 miles away! That was mid-August, so we foresaw a day of overheated radiators and short tempers. We pulled off the third exit at Geneva and headed down to Keuka Lake, where my future wife had a cottage, and had invited me. I feel secure in saying that Katie and I enjoyed that weekend more than the people who were at the event. We had two days of drinking, laughing, swimming and boating, with a modern toilet at our disposal, instead of being in Bethel in the mud, a gazillion miles from the stage. We eventually watched the show in comfort in an air-conditioned theater, like all of you. I do not regret skipping the live concert, not even one little bit.
But I do regret that Katie and I never made it to that production of Godspell.

Godspell’s original Toronto cast in 1972 (l-r, back row): Avril Chown, Victor Garber, Gilda Radner, Gerry Salsberg, Martin Short, Eugene Levy, Rudy Webb; (front row kneeling): Valda Aviks. Not shown: Andrea Martin and Jayne Eastwood
The other side of the story:
The Toronto Star printed two very different reviews. One critic loved everything about the cast and the first half. He wasn’t thrilled with what came after intermission, but he concluded that the cast justly deserved its many curtain calls on the basis of the first act alone.
The other reviewer hated the play itself, which I can understand completely, but he did not have harsh words for the cast.
The Playbill:

The final cast:
People rarely mention that Levy, who was just another one of the clowns (Herb) in the original cast, was later cast as Jesus in the final months, as the cast rotated through. That’s a role that actually requires a real singer, and he demonstrated in You Had to Be There that he can still sing quite well.
In the documentary, somebody mentioned that the casting of Dave Thomas to replace Levy as Herb was inexplicable because he can’t dance at all, even though the show requires energetic dancing! Below is a rarely-seen photo of future SCTV castmates Thomas and Levy, during the months when Levy played Jesus.

Below is a publicity picture of the final cast, which starred Eugene as Jesus. At the top – Valda Aviks, Rudy Webb, Dave Thomas; 2nd row – Jim Betts, Mary Ann McDonald, Avril Chown, Beth Anne Cole; Front row – Karl Blindheim, Patti Elsasser.
Gilda Radner, Andrea Martin and Martin Short had left the cast by then.




“and the NY Thruway was jammed”
87 was jammed with broken heroes On a last chance power drive
Together, Katie, we can live with the sadness
I’ll love you with all the madness in my soul
Oh, someday girl, I don’t know when
We’re gonna get to that place
Where we really want to go, and we’ll walk in the sun
Many years later
I found myself talking to this girl
Who was standing there
With her back turned to Lake Keuka
The wind was blowing
Especially through her hair
There was four Italian sausages
Cooking on the outdoor grill
And they were sizzlin’
Aah baby, we gotta go now
Unfortunately, I was born to walk … slowly … after looking both ways.
Thanks for this!
I just watched “Greatest Show You Never Heard Of” and started in on all the SCTVs, which are on Netflix. So perfect timing.
Pretty incredible that to think Dave Thomas did all this while making his delicious hamburgers
Martin Short looks taller than Eugene Levy. I didn’t think Martin Short was taller than anybody. And Levy seems to be trying to pick one of Short’s pockets.
That caught my eye as well. By that trick of perspective, he seems to be taller than Victor Garber (in the Superman shirt), who is a six-footer.
Big Ugly: When I kill her, it’ll be the greatest event since the Crucifixion. And I should know. I was there.
Spike: You were there? Oh, please! If every vampire who said he was at the Crucifixion was actually there, it would have been like Woodstock.
Big Ugly: I oughta rip your throat out.
Spike: I was actually at Woodstock. That was a weird gig. I fed off a flower person, and I spent the next six hours watchin’ my hand move.
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Avril Chown had a pretty successful career changing file permissions in Linux.
Her cousin Chmod hit the jackpot in Vegas too on the slots. 777.
As I think that I have mentioned here before, I lived and breathed SCTV when I was a teenager and young adult – the broadcast was often the highlight of my week, and much discussed and re-enacted with friends afterwards. I am a fan of a lot of other comedy too, but nothing quite has ever matched SCTV in my estimation (with an exception maybe of ‘Spinal Tap’ for which I literally fell off of my seat laughing when I first saw it at the theatre).
Given my dedicated fandom, I was at the premiere for ‘You Had to Be There’ last year with my wife at TIFF. It was an enjoyable experience and an eduction into the origin story of a generation of comedy in North America. The documentary was a bit limited by the lack of footage from the actual Godspell production itself (aside from a clandestine audio recording by Martin Short) – it is mostly a ‘talking heads’ documentary featuring those involved providing their recollections. But I still thought that it was great.
Additional fun fact (if I remember correctly): Catherine O’Hara was also already hanging out with those folks at the time of Godspell Toronto production and auditioned for a part, but did not make it onto the cast.
Wow. Victor Garber?
He’s not somebody we think of either as a singer or as a funny guy, but he was so good in that role that he was chosen to play the part in the film version, and was the only member of the Toronto cast so chosen. Garber has mentioned in interviews that the stage play allows the performers to incorporate their own personalities into the production, and that the Toronto cast therefore provided humor that was not on the page. One wonders if the unsuccessful film could have been a hit if it had simply embedded the comic sensibility of the Toronto cast into the production rather than the earnestness that made the film so drab.
Unusual Godspell trivia: The London cast also produced a major star, but not in comedy. The part of John/Judas was played by that wacky cut-up Jeremy Irons!
The film is online for free, by the way.
He’s also got four Tony nominations, including two for musicals. But yeah it’s funny his TV/movie persona is straight man (no pun intended, he’s gay).
Hard to believe one Toronto production of Godspell fed so many people into SNL and SCTV, with Paul Shaffer as musical director on top of that. Rehearsal footage and Martin Short’s bootleg recording make the documentary sound worth tracking down.
just wanted to chime in. you will not see a post like this, or a thread and discussion like this, anywhere else.
this is fascinating, and well put together. shows that “the internet” can be a very human place with great interactions and convo.